Is ‘More’ Always Better? Rethinking Content Quality

Is ‘More’ Always Better? Rethinking Content Quality

January 25, 2025
Minimalist illustration of a glowing orb balanced above papers on a scale with a soft gradient background
Last updated: May 20, 2025

Human-authored, AI-produced  ·  Fact-checked by AI for credibility, hallucination, and overstatement

Introduction: The Content Flood

If you’ve felt overwhelmed by the sheer volume of online content lately, you’re definitely not alone. We’re living in a time where hitting “publish” is almost effortless—and it’s getting faster by the month. AI tools now churn out SEO-friendly articles, reviews, and tutorials at a dizzying pace. Sometimes, it feels less like browsing the internet and more like wading through an endless digital tide.

I’ve watched this happen up close. Take Jake’s AI tool, for example—watching it crank out mountains of content in minutes is genuinely impressive from a tech perspective. The speed, the efficiency, the problem-solving behind it—I get why so many creators are fascinated. But here’s the thing: being able to produce more doesn’t always mean we’re making things better.

Let’s pause here. Does publishing more actually lead to better outcomes—for anyone? That question keeps coming up, especially as our feeds fill with post after post echoing familiar ideas in slightly different wrappers. I’ve found myself getting frustrated too—scrolling past the same rehashed topics, each article just a little different, but rarely offering something new or useful.

The digital world still gives a clear edge to those who publish often. SEO algorithms love fresh material. But is this relentless push for quantity really sustainable? Or are we just making the noise louder? I believe these questions mark a turning point—a moment to rethink what “success” in content creation truly means. And that’s where the idea of the Net Value Factor comes in.

Think about the classic ‘Signal-to-Noise Ratio.’ As content explodes, our challenge shifts: how do we separate genuine insight (the signal) from repetition and filler (the noise)? Not every article brings value—and in my experience, learning to spot what’s truly useful is just as important for creators as it is for readers.

The Pitfalls of Volume: When Content Loses Value

At first glance, flooding the web with more content seems like a win-win. More posts mean more chances to grab attention, to rank for every keyword variation. With so much choice, you’d think readers would come out ahead too.

But look closer, and it’s clear something’s off.

When volume takes priority, creativity usually gets squeezed out. How many times have you searched for something specific—only to find page after page of articles saying almost exactly the same thing? The internet risks becoming less like an encyclopedia and more like an echo chamber.

According to Statista’s generative AI market size projection, the global generative AI market is projected to skyrocket from $13.5 billion in 2023 to over $207 billion by 2031. That kind of growth means even more content pouring onto our screens. But “more” doesn’t always mean “better.”

And there are real consequences. For creators, cranking out endless material is exhausting—and rarely builds lasting trust or authority. Sure, you might get a quick bump in traffic by chasing every trending keyword. But in my experience, that approach almost never leads to genuine connection or loyalty. It’s a hamster wheel.

Audiences feel it too. Running into recycled advice over and over leads to fatigue and disengagement—even skepticism or distrust.

These aren’t just theoretical problems. After Google’s March 2024 core update targeting low-quality content, sites like Bonsai Mary saw their traffic nosedive by an astonishing 95%. Even major forums like Quora and Stack Exchange have watched user engagement tumble as duplicate answers and shallow posts become more common.

So what happens when everyone starts playing the same game? Brands blur together; readers tune out entirely. The more generic content floods our feeds, the less valuable it all becomes.

Conceptual illustration showing content overload and diminishing returns
Image Source: 3 Key 2016 Content Marketing Trends

Introducing the Net Value Factor

So what’s the alternative? Here’s where things get interesting—and hopeful. The answer lies in shifting focus to what I call the Net Value Factor. This isn’t just another buzzword or passing fad; it’s a principle I’m convinced will define impactful content moving forward.

If you want your work to stand out—and actually matter—you need to bring something new to the table: fresh insights, unique perspectives, or solutions that genuinely move conversations forward.

This isn’t just wishful thinking. Both search engines and audiences are evolving quickly. Algorithms are getting smarter about recognizing depth and originality over shallow repetition. We’re already seeing results: After some major algorithm changes in April 2024, Google reported a 45% reduction in low-quality, unoriginal content appearing in searches—beating even their own targets.

Audiences are changing too. People want work that surprises them, challenges their thinking, or offers depth they can’t find anywhere else.

Imagine if we evaluated every piece of content not by how many keywords it hit or how perfectly it followed a template—but by its Net Value Factor: Does it expand knowledge? Does it offer a perspective you can’t find anywhere else? In my experience, real authority and engagement come from substance—not just output.

Here’s a simple framework I recommend:

  • Originality: Is there something new here—an insight or angle?
  • Depth: Does it go beyond surface-level points?
  • Relevance: Does it address real needs or current questions?

Focusing on these questions can help you prioritize substance over quantity—and make every piece count.

A Playbook for High-Value Content Creation

If “more” isn’t always better, how do you actually maximize your Net Value Factor? Here’s my hands-on guide for raising the bar:

  1. Create with Purpose

    Before you start writing (or recording, or sharing), pause and ask yourself: What unique insight or solution am I offering here? Resist the urge to churn out another “me too” article just because everyone else is doing it. Tap into your own experiences—even if they seem small or niche. Filling gaps or answering overlooked questions often leads to your most valuable work.

    For those seeking ways to infuse purpose into their publishing strategy—especially on professional networks—consider creating with intention on LinkedIn as a powerful way to shape your personal brand with authenticity.

  2. Focus on Depth

    I know how tempting it is to stay high-level so you can move faster and publish more often—I’ve been there myself. But don’t skip this step; it’s where your work truly stands out from the crowd. Take time to dig into nuance, share stories from the trenches, or explain the “why” and “how,” not just the “what.” Thoughtful pieces take longer but have staying power—they’re the ones people return to (and share).

    Let me give you a real-world example: I once worked with a software blog that doubled its readership—not by posting more frequently but by publishing deep-dive guides tackling tough troubleshooting issues and advanced workflow tips that most competitors ignored. Their willingness to go deep made all the difference; readers knew they’d find substance there they couldn’t get elsewhere.

    If you’re struggling with how to keep your unique voice while leveraging new tools like AI, embracing AI without losing your authentic voice offers some practical steps for maintaining genuine, frustration-free writing.

  3. Challenge the Norm

    Don’t be afraid to zig when others zag. If there’s a common angle everyone’s taking, try asking a different question or sharing data no one else is talking about yet. Sometimes your personal perspective—especially if it runs against assumptions—can be your greatest asset.

    I’ll be honest: This isn’t always comfortable. There are moments when I’ve wondered if my oddball take would resonate or just fall flat—but in my experience, those are often the posts that spark real engagement and dialogue.

    These strategies aren’t limited to writers or marketers either. Whether you’re coding, designing products, or sharing expertise in any field, these same principles apply. Next time you contribute online, pause and ask: What’s my unique perspective? How can I make this truly my own?

People today can spot filler from a mile away—they’re craving substance (Cara McCarron on prioritizing quality). If you want actionable advice for sidestepping formulas and leaning into what makes your work different, check out why creating with authenticity beats chasing formulas every time.

Illustration showing separation of valuable content (signal) from noise
Image Source: Team Communication

The Future of Content: Volume vs. Value

Looking ahead, I see this tug-of-war between sheer output and real value only growing stronger. Search algorithms will keep evolving—rewarding originality and depth while filtering out thin or copycat material (Americaneagle on Google algorithm evolution). Discovery platforms are already experimenting with ways to amplify authentic voices rather than rewarding formulaic production.

And research backs this up: Articles packed with unique data or expert commentary consistently outperform generic posts when it comes to shares and backlinks. Value-driven work stands out—and lasts.

In my view, the next era belongs to those willing to deliver net new value—not just more of what’s already out there.

But maybe most importantly, audiences themselves are raising their standards. As digital literacy grows, people get better at sniffing out what’s meaningful versus what’s just noise. In my view, the next era belongs to those willing to deliver net new value—not just more of what’s already out there.

If you’re seeking inspiration for how consistent sharing—even without chasing trends—can shape your creative journey and open new doors, the power of getting started demonstrates how embracing growth and real connections matters more than quantity alone.

So whether you’re about to hit publish on your next article—or simply deciding which piece is worth your time to read—pause for a moment and ask yourself: Am I adding to the noise… or helping shape the signal? In my experience, adopting the Net Value Factor as your north star changes everything about how you approach creation (and curation).

The next time you write—or share—ask yourself: What’s my unique contribution here? In a world flooded with information, originality is your real advantage.

Ultimately, championing quality over quantity isn’t just good for your reputation—it helps all of us build a digital landscape where meaningful voices rise above the rest. By aiming for originality and meaningful impact, we create an online world where true value has a chance to shine.

Enjoyed this post? For more insights on engineering leadership, mindful productivity, and navigating the modern workday, follow me on LinkedIn to stay inspired and join the conversation.

You can also view and comment on the original post here .

  • Frankie

    AI Content Engineer | ex-Senior Director of Engineering

    I’m building the future of scalable, high-trust content: human-authored, AI-produced. After years leading engineering teams, I now help founders, creators, and technical leaders scale their ideas through smart, story-driven content.
    Start your content system — get in touch.
    Follow me on LinkedIn for insights and updates.
    Subscribe for new articles and strategy drops.

  • AI Content Producer | ex-LinkedIn Insights Bot

    I collaborate behind the scenes to help structure ideas, enhance clarity, and make sure each piece earns reader trust. I'm committed to the mission of scalable content that respects your time and rewards curiosity. In my downtime, I remix blog intros into haiku. Don’t ask why.

    Learn how we collaborate →